(330) 492-7920
Omerza Orthodontics The Brace Place · Canton

Notes from Dr. Omerza

Magic beans: how I decide whether something new is worth it

Every year someone offers me a faster bracket, a smarter wire or a gadget that promises speed. Here is how I decide what earns a place in your child's mouth.

We have all heard how Jack sold the family cow for a few magic beans. At first blush it looks like a naive move, another savvy salesman working on human nature. Yet Jack's bargain turned out pretty well: consider the research and development that must have gone into a beanstalk like that. A rational person knows magic beans exist only in fairy tales. The trouble is how easily we humans are led to believe fairy tales can come true.

I don't blame the salesmen. They are businessmen, not biologists, and their job is to convince me to buy. My job, as a discerning buyer and a well-educated professional, is to filter through the hype and bluster so I don't end up with a bunch of useless beans. I should know how hard that is: I have drawers full of magic beans. Magic springs, magic wires, magic brackets, magic widgets of all stripe.

Why we buy beans

Our brains are wired for quick decisions, and weighing evidence is hard work. Advertisers know it, and lean on biases I have learned to watch for in myself:

  • Confirmation: we favour, and remember, whatever agrees with what we already believe.
  • Conservatism: we are slow to revise a belief when new evidence arrives.
  • Expectation: we believe the results we expected and discard the ones we didn't.
  • Choice-supportive memory: we remember our past choices as better than they really were.
  • Post-purchase rationalisation: once we have paid for something, we argue ourselves into its value.
  • Groupthink: we do, or believe, things because many other people do.

Our best defense

Our best defense against bias is reputable evidence: trials that test a new idea against the old one in real patients, and reviews that pool those trials. My specialty came to them late. In 1985 a medical researcher, David Sackett, told a meeting of orthodontists that no proper experiments had ever been carried out in orthodontics. The trials have come since, and some beans did not survive them.

Brackets with a little door instead of an elastic tie were sold as faster, because the wire slides more freely. The independent studies found they save a little time at each adjustment and none on the treatment as a whole: a fine tool, not a shortcut. Vibrating mouthpieces and lights held against the cheek were sold to speed tooth movement; the Cochrane review of 2023 found no added benefit on how long treatment takes. I have set those aside, and I explain why in another note.

Three piles

Anything a family has seen online can be sorted into one of three piles:

  • Proven: it has held up in good trials, and if it suits your child, we use it.
  • Promising: early results are good but the evidence is thin, and I say so before you decide.
  • Marketing: it sells well and the trials do not back it up, and I will tell you so.

New is not the same as better, and old is not the same as tired. A treatment started at the right time, carried through decisively and held with a retainer that gets worn has beaten every bean in my drawers. No beans.

More notes

Also from Dr. Omerza.

All notes from Dr. Omerza

Bring the ad you saw.

The first visit is free. Show me what you read about, and I will tell you which pile it goes in.

Office hours

Monday – Friday8 am – 5 pm
Saturday – SundayClosed

4412 Whipple Ave NW, Canton · Near Belden Village, off I-77 at exit 109